JDH Welcome, what part of Canada are you from? Im from Buffalo so its basically both countries
Your story is kinda like mine in some ways. My brother and I got a Saturn in late 1996 during XMAS. Parents got the 3 Free Game Deal.
As 10-11 year olds we had no choice and my parents thought it would be the next big system. We gave it a good 1.5-2 years of love before getting a PS1 and N64... then DC and PC.
Like you, despite owning a PS1 and being able to play ALL of the great titles (RE2, Silent Hill, Dino Crisis, Gran Turismo, Metal Gear Solid).... the Saturn love remained the strongest when I got older. Maybe it was that everyone was against it. Maybe its because as a Saturn owner you felt you were in a small exclusive club.
Its never too late to start re-collecting. Although my re-interest came back in 2006 and it was certainly easier and cheaper to start up again...
We also only owned maybe 10-12 titles when I was a kid too. But they all offered something unique as Saturn versions. My memory is sometimes blurry about a couple titles if they were borrowed from friends and kept or not.
Virtua Cop, Virtual Fighter 2, Daytona USA, Area 51, Sega Rally, Sonic 3D Blast, Fighting Vipers, Quake, Duke Nukem 3D, Alien Trilogy. Borrowed ones: Nights, Myst, Tomb Raider. Also remember playing the heck out of the demos for Clockwork Knight, Bug, Nights, Panzer Dragoon, and Baku Baku.
But the nostalgia for the games I read about in magazines is what really brought me back to collect. Games I never had the means to buy but wanted: Burning Rangers, Sonic R, Congo, Powerslave, Last Bronx, Steep Slope Sliders, Bomberman, Hercs Adventures, Croc.